Ep. 5: Real Estate Horror Stories — Get Rich or Rent Trying

Recorded October 1; about 26 minutes.

Summary

It’s Halloween season, so Richard, Ohizua and Sergio trade the deals that went sideways: 18 W-2s on one mortgage file, a buyer who ghosted after a year of showings, an $18,000 personal loan taken out the week before closing, a Yonkers listing that took from August to May, and a rocking chair found under a living-room floor. Every story ends with the same lesson for Long Island buyers and sellers: a deal is not done until the keys change hands, so protect it from your own side first.

What happened in the episode

Richard opens with a story from his loan officer days: three borrowers, seasonal W-2s from the same landscaping company, 18 W-2s in all, and a $950,000 purchase that was approved, re-reviewed, and dead. Ohizua follows with the buyer he drove from Queens to Suffolk County for almost a year: more than 20 showings, one offer, an inspection with minor findings, then silence. Sergio’s buyer was clear to close when he took out an $18,000 personal loan a week before the table; the only way to save the deal was to buy his rate down from about 6.25% to 5.25%, which turned a commission of roughly $10,000 into about $1,500. Richard’s million-dollar Yonkers listing stalled five months on an open permit, then nearly died over a retaining wall the buyer’s attorney wanted removed. Sergio adds a live one: a buyer who won’t close until the certificate of occupancy for a finished basement is in, and wants $50,000 to $100,000 held in escrow. Ohizua closes with a Cleveland flip where the crew tore up a squeaky floor and found a rocking chair underneath.

Three takeaways

  • Nothing changes between contract and closing. Lenders are notified when a borrower’s credit is pulled, and they re-check income and debt before funding. No new loans, no new cards, no financed furniture, no job changes until after you close.
  • Open permits and missing certificates of occupancy are the slowest delays on Long Island. If you are selling, pull your permit and CO history before you list. If you are buying, decide early whether you will accept an escrow holdback or insist on the paperwork, because “any day now” from a town can mean months.
  • Communication keeps deals, and relationships, alive. A buyer who has stopped looking owes the agent a text, not a disappearance. And a loan officer’s job starts, not ends, at the accepted offer: Richard’s Brooklyn condo approval landed at 3:30 p.m. on a 5 p.m. deadline day, after he had already called everyone to say it was over.

In their words

“That deal went from August to May of just delay, delay, delay. And at the end of the day, we got it done.”

— Richard Alvarez, on the Yonkers listing

“Basically now his debt ratio didn’t work. So, we had to lower the rate just to make him qualify.”

— Sergio Lopez, on the $18,000 personal loan

“It’s one thing to be ghosted by your significant other, but when you get ghosted professionally, it hurts more.”

— Ohizua Russel

FAQ for Long Island buyers and sellers

I’m under contract. What should I not do before closing?

No new debt (personal loans, car loans, credit cards, financed appliances), no job changes, no co-signing, and no large transfers without a paper trail. Your lender re-verifies credit, employment and assets before funding, and one new monthly payment can push your debt-to-income ratio over the limit. If something has to change, call your loan officer first.

My house has a finished basement without a permit or CO. Can I still sell?

Yes. Unpermitted work is common on Long Island, and you have three routes: legalize it before listing (plan on months, and expect your assessment and taxes to reflect the added living space), sell as-is and let the buyer decide, or agree at contract to an escrow holdback so the sale closes while the paperwork catches up. Have your attorney run the municipal search early.

Can a buyer switch lenders after signing the contract?

Yes. A borrower can change lenders at any point up to closing; a realtor’s commission is set by the contract, but a loan officer’s is not guaranteed until the loan funds. Switching late restarts the appraisal and underwriting and can blow your mortgage-contingency or commitment date, so get a second opinion on your rate in the first two weeks, not the last.

Why do New York closings take so long?

New York closings involve attorneys on both sides, a contract signed after inspection, a lender commitment, title and municipal searches, and, for condos and co-ops, a board review. Sixty to ninety days from contract is typical when everything is clean; open permits, missing COs, title issues and lender turn times are what stretch it toward the nine months Richard describes. Build in a cushion, especially if you are selling and buying at the same time.

Watch the episode

Thinking about selling?

Know what your home is worth and what could slow the sale down before you list. Get a free home value estimate at teammodernx.com/how-much-is-my-home-worth, or contact Richard and Team Modern X in West Hempstead, in English or Spanish. We have the horror stories so you don’t have to.

Discover

Latest Posts

Compare listings

Compare