Long Island market update: September 2026

Long Island’s housing market kept its footing in September. Prices rose again in both counties, homes still sold in about a month, and buyers had a few more choices than they did in the spring. Here is what the September 2026 numbers say, and what they mean if you are selling or buying this fall.

Nassau County: prices up about 2 percent, still a seller’s market

The median single-family sale price in Nassau was $860,000 in September, up about 2 percent from September 2025, according to OneKey MLS. Closed sales were down about 4 percent from a year earlier, new listings were down about 10 percent, and about 2,300 single-family homes were for sale county-wide, roughly three months of supply. Homes sold in a median of 40 days on the MLS (Redfin’s figure for all home types is 31 days), and the typical seller received 99.8 percent of the original asking price. Redfin shows about half of Nassau homes selling above list.

In plain language: Nassau is no longer a frenzy, but a well-priced house still draws competing offers inside a few weeks. The August median was higher, so do not read one month as a trend; the year-over-year direction is still up.

Suffolk County: more sales, higher prices

Suffolk had the stronger month. The median single-family price was $740,000, up about 3 percent from a year earlier, and closed sales rose about 5 percent to just over 1,000. Inventory was about 3 percent lower than last September at roughly 3,200 homes, again about three months of supply. Homes went under contract in a median of 40 days (31 on Redfin’s count), sellers received about 101 percent of original asking on average, and nearly two thirds of Suffolk homes sold above list. Suffolk stays the more competitive county because the entry price is lower and buyers priced out of Nassau keep moving east.

West Hempstead: a strong month for our home town

Closer to home, Redfin reports a median West Hempstead sale price of about $825,000 in September, up about 8.5 percent from a year earlier, with 31 homes sold and a median of 34 days on market. Volume was lower than last September mostly because there is not much to buy: Zillow counted 54 homes for sale in 11552 at the end of the month, with 15 new listings, a median list price of about $822,000 and a typical home value of about $800,000, up almost 6 percent over the past year. If you own here, you have equity you may not have had two years ago.

Queens: houses hold, co-ops and condos climb

For anyone who straddles the city line, Queens is worth watching. PropertyShark’s recorded sales show a median Queens sale price of about $740,000 in September across all property types, up about 6.5 percent from a year earlier. Houses held at about $955,000, condos rose to about $706,000 and co-ops to about $345,000. Queens co-ops remain the lowest-cost way to own in the metro area, and many of our Long Island buyers start in exactly those apartments.

What this means if you are selling

The spring surge is over, but the fundamentals have not changed: inventory is thin, prices are up year over year, and homes priced on real comparable sales go under contract in four to six weeks at or above asking. The homes that sit are the ones priced on hope. Redfin shows about 17 percent of Nassau listings and 30 percent of West Hempstead listings taking a price cut, which is what happens when a house is listed at the number the owner wants rather than the number the last three sales support. Price it right on day one and you will likely have your pick of offers before Thanksgiving.

What this means if you are buying

You have slightly more choice than you did in May, and sellers whose homes have sat for 45 days or more are more open to a deal. Mortgage rates are the wild card; if they drift down, competition comes back fast. Get fully pre-approved now, settle your must-haves, and be ready to act the week a house you like comes on. Well-priced homes still go in about a month, and the best ones go faster.

Find out what your home is worth right now

These are county and town medians; your house is not a median. If you are thinking about selling in Nassau, Suffolk, Queens or the Bronx in the next year, Richard will send you a free, no-obligation estimate based on the sales nearest you, within 24 hours, with no pressure and no algorithm.

Get my free home value   Contact Richard

County detail, updated monthly: Nassau, Suffolk, Queens and the Bronx, West Hempstead.

Sources: OneKey MLS September 2026 county reports (Nassau, Suffolk); Redfin, September 2026 (Nassau County, Suffolk County, West Hempstead); Zillow, September 30, 2026 (ZIP 11552); PropertyShark, September 2026 (Queens). Figures are rounded. Team Modern X, Jason Mitchell Real Estate NY, 45 Cherry Valley Ave, West Hempstead, NY 11552.

Discover

Latest Posts

Compare listings

Compare